Wednesday, September 08, 2010 Login     

 

 
Meet Dr. Bob

Dr. Bob, a prominent cardiologist, tells Susan, his transcriptionist of 10 years, that he has purchased an EMR package and will no longer need her assistance.  He will miss her, but looks forward to the elimination of transcription as a sure way to save money for his practice, as his EMR vendor promised him would be the case.

Dr. Bob's EMR package has a front-end voice recognition system that he plans to train and utilize for charting his patient encounters.  Initially, he decreases his patient load by 10 patients per day, about two hours, so that he can spend that two hours training the voice rec engine.  The engine requires that he dictate slowly and with punctuation, and often the time needed exceeds the two hours he allowed.  He also assumes the responsibility of editing his own reports and typing his corrections.  Dr. Bob, while an excellent cardiologist, types a mere 30 words per minute, so this task proves slow and painful for him.

After two weeks, Dr. Bob has made some progress in the training of his engine, but does not realize that some of the abbreviations he likes to use are supposed to be typed out long-hand, per national guidelines.  He adds an hour to his day for a week, so that he can re-train the engine to type out these abbreviations the way his transcriptionist always just did for him.

Another two weeks goes by, and Dr. Bob seems to be on-course for reaching his goals of saving money by eliminating his transcriptionist.  Dictating into his computer ties him to his desk, but this seems a small price to pay for improving his bottom line.  While he still stays late at the office every night to complete the training process, he feels he is getting home a little earlier every night, so stays the course.  

Thirty days has passed and Dr. Bob feels his voice recognition documents are accurate enough that he does not have to continue the training process.  He's confident that simple review of his documents is all that is needed now, and he's sure that eliminating 12 cent per line transcription was a good decision.  It is time to ramp back up to his usual capacity of 40 patients per day.

Dr. Bob begins the task of dictating and editing notes for the 40 patients he sees each day.  At the end of another month, he throws his hands up in frustration and calls Susan to please take over the documentation task for him once again.

  
What happened?

The pitfalls of front-end speech recognition have kicked in, and Dr. Bob is saving neither time nor money.   

Nugget:  There is no elimination of the transcription process, only re-assignment of the task. Someone somewhere has to be paid to review the document. 

Let's look at this closely.  We can use some national guidelines from AHDI (Association for Health Data Integrity) to help us with production ratios.  AHDI says, and CMT certification requires:

One minute of dictation = 11 lines of charting

One minute of dictation = 4 minutes of transcription or 1-2 minutes of editing for well-trained MLS

Let's make the assumption that Dr. Bob's hourly rate is $150/hr and he dictates 2 mins/pt, or 80 mins/day 

Producing the Note:

Self-Editing by Dr. Bob                   2 mins/encounter, 40 pt/day, 80 mins at $150/hr                                   cost:  $200/day

Transcription by Susan                 80 mins of dictation (2 mins/pt), 880 lines, 12 cents per line                    cost:  $105.60/day                                                                                         

And this doesn't include any training or re-training time for the voice rec engine nor missed patient time and revenue.

Even assuming Dr. Bob is just as fast as Susan, the cost for Dr. Bob to assume this responsibility is almost twice as much as hiring Susan to do this for him.  He'd have to be twice as fast as Susan just to break even. If Dr. Bob edits between 80 and 160 minutes per day (2-4 mins per patient), he's taking 2-4 hours every day away from seeing patients and generating revenue to perform a task that could be delegated to someone who can do it faster and probably more accurately, as well.

 

How much revenue do your patients generate ??  All of it .

  
Takeaway:

A physician's most important task is seeing patients.  If you're wanting to save time and money,

redirecting the time of a costly physician to duties that can be delegated to qualified,

less expensive team members just doesn't make "cents."

  
Home  |  About Us  |  Charting Options  |  Cutting Costs  |  Contact Us  |  Training  |  eRemote  |  CEO's Blog
Copyright 2009 by ELTS  | Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement